EN DE
STOCK COMPARISON

First Majestic Silver vs Aya Gold & Silver: Fair Value & Quality

Both stocks run through our valuation models. Here is how First Majestic Silver (AG) and Aya Gold & Silver (AYA) compare, as of Aug 14, 2026.

As of Aug 14, 2026, Fair Value Calculator sees First Majestic Silver as the less overvalued of the two: First Majestic Silver trades at $18.78 versus a fair value of $4.91 (-74%), while Aya Gold & Silver trades at C$37.44 versus C$4.59 (-88%).
First Majestic Silver
AG · USD · Materials
-74%
upside to fair value
overvalued
Price$18.78
Fair Value$4.91
Quality49/100
Aya Gold & Silver
AYA.TO · CAD · Materials
-88%
upside to fair value
overvalued
PriceC$37.44
Fair ValueC$4.59
Quality49/100

Head-to-head numbers

Green value = the better side for that row (for valuation multiples: lower = cheaper).

First Majestic SilverAya Gold & Silver
Valuation
28.7×P/E (TTM)45.0×
5.62×P/S (TTM)9.99×
3.04×P/B6.90×
9.9×EV/EBITDA18.1×
0.2%Dividend yield—
$0.04Dividend per share—
Profitability
20%Net margin30%
50%Operating margin66%
11%Return on equity24%
8%Return on assets15%
Growth
95%Revenue growth (YoY)247%
26.8%Avg. growth/yr (3Y)74.2%
28.4%Avg. growth/yr (5Y)71.0%
Balance & size
0.11×Debt / equity0.20×
$8BMarket cap$3B
mixedGrowth qualitymixed

Aya Gold & Silver leads: 5 to 7 metric wins.

Dash = not meaningfully computable, for example with negative equity.

Quality in detail

The quality score, broken down into the same factor families as on the stock page, 0 to 100 per family.

First Majestic Silverof which business quality 54 · market factors 39 Aya Gold & Silverof which business quality 51 · market factors 69
ProfitabilityMargins and returns on capital today
31
46
Quality GrowthAre margins and returns improving?
80
100
CashflowEarnings quality: real cash, not paper profit
86
45
Fin. StrengthBalance sheet, leverage, solvency risk
88
92
InvestmentDisciplined investing over empire-building
6
0
Low VolatilityCalm price path (market factor)
0
4
MomentumPrice trend over the last 3–12 months (market factor)
44
95
52W MomentumDistance to the 52-week high (market factor)
73
100
Net IssuanceBuybacks instead of dilution
0
0

What the models say

The median fair value (base case) per model family, each in the currency of its trading venue. Green = above the current price, red = below.

First Majestic Silver

DCF Models$16.40
Earnings-Based$11.89
Dividend Discount$0.33
Multiples$5.78
Asset-Based$3.74
Growth DCF$15.82
Economic Profit$4.61
Growth Earnings$14.63

23 of 26 models see the stock below the current price.

Aya Gold & Silver

Earnings-BasedC$11.12
MultiplesC$5.40
Asset-BasedC$1.93
Economic ProfitC$2.84
Growth EarningsC$13.68

14 of 14 models see the stock below the current price.

Scenario ranges

From our cautious bear case to the optimistic bull case. The white tick is the current price: left of fair value means room to run.

First Majestic Silver
Bear $3.68Fair Value $4.91Bull $6.14
$18.78 = current price (white tick)
Aya Gold & Silver
Bear C$3.44Fair Value C$4.59Bull C$5.74
C$37.44 = current price (white tick)

Compare two other stocks

Tap a field and type again, ticker or company name.

Free, no sign-up

Ranked within their sector

Where each stock sits within its sector peer group. Band = middle 50% of peers, tick = median, dot = this stock.

First Majestic Silver · Materials

Quality score49 · below median
Fair value upside-74% · bottom 25%

Aya Gold & Silver · Materials

Quality score49 · below median
Fair value upside-88% · bottom 25%

Bottom line

As of Aug 14, 2026, Fair Value Calculator sees First Majestic Silver as the less overvalued of the two: First Majestic Silver trades at $18.78 versus a fair value of $4.91 (-74%), while Aya Gold & Silver trades at C$37.44 versus C$4.59 (-88%).

Aya Gold & Silver has the higher quality score (49/100).

See the full analysis →
First Majestic Silver · Aya Gold & Silver

More comparisons

Popular match-ups from the same sectors, all with fair value and quality score.

Related to First Majestic Silver

Alphabet Inc Class C vs Verizon CommunicationsAlphabet Inc Class C vs At&tAlphabet Inc Class C vs NetEaseAmazon.com vs Toyota Motor Corporation

Related to Aya Gold & Silver

Amazon.com vs PDD HoldingsAmazon.com vs Sony GroupMeta Platforms vs Verizon CommunicationsMeta Platforms vs At&t
Free · Top-25 report

See the undervalued quality stocks every month

Just your email for the monthly Top-25 report of the most undervalued quality stocks, with fair value, quality and price target. Plus 14 days of Pro to try, no card.

Free. You confirm by email (double opt-in) and can unsubscribe anytime in one click. Not financial advice.

A model-based valuation snapshot from 21 models. Values change with price and fundamentals; the date shown above applies.